Essendon Bombers – AFL Fantasy Analysis 2024
Heff · January 10, 2024

Essendon’s 2023 season was a blend of promise and disappointment, but as a result, AFL Fantasy coaches stand to uncover some good value players in 2024. Their inconsistent year provides us with a mix of undervalued players and potential breakout stars, offering ample opportunities in 2024 for AFL Fantasy coaches to capitalize on. This analysis delves into the Bombers’ squad, spotlighting players who offer significant fantasy potential. As we explore these key Essendon players, we’ll focus on those poised to provide substantial returns in the upcoming AFL Fantasy season.
The Undervalued
Jye Caldwell
Jye Caldwell’s AFL fantasy potential for 2024 is shaping up to be quite intriguing. If he were listed purely as a midfielder, I wouldn’t bother writing about him. However, the fact that he’s classified as a forward in AFL Fantasy makes him a more compelling option for the upcoming season. I anticipate that Caldwell will take on various accountable roles in the midfield, and he might even be utilized as a tagger at times. While such roles aren’t typically fantasy goldmines, his forward classification should secure him a consistent average above 75. This consistency makes him a valuable asset for this year. I’m still on the fence about whether he can improve on his fantasy scoring and provide even greater value down the line, but for 2024, Caldwell stands out as a handy option to bolster our line-ups.
Jade Gresham
It’s probably worth noting that I’ll likely be discussing any player listed as a forward who delivers even moderately decent fantasy returns in these articles. While I’m not anticipating a dramatic shift from his last season’s performance at St Kilda, Gresham’s role as a forward makes him slightly more valuable than in past seasons. He’s likely to replicate the same role as at St Kilda’s at Essendon, contributing in the forward line while pitching in the midfield. In the often scarce landscape of forward options in AFL Fantasy, players like Gresham are worth owning. His consistent performance, though not earth-shattering, presents a valuable asset given the general dearth of high-performing forwards in the game.
Xavier Duursma
Xavier Duursma’s trade to Essendon came with promises of more time in the inside midfield, but frankly, I’m skeptical about that happening. Duursma’s skill set aligns more with that of an outside player rather than an inside type. At Essendon, there are already established players like Zach Merrett, Darcy Parish, Jye Caldwell, and Ben Hobbs, not to mention Sam Durham, who I’ll be discussing next, earmarked for an inside midfield role next season. We’ve also had news of Nic Martin heading to the half-back line which looks like he’s making way for Duursma on the wing. Given this, it’s hard to see where Duursma fits into the inside midfield mix. While players often get a scoring bump when moving to a new club, I’d temper expectations for Duursma, projecting maybe a 75 to 85 average at best.
Sam Durham
Sam Durham’s role at Essendon is one to watch closely. As a winger, he’s adequately valued at his average from last season. However, Zach Merrett’s recent press conference hinted at Durham potentially moving into an inside role. While he does possess the skills for this position, it’s uncertain how he’ll integrate with Essendon’s crowded midfield lineup, which includes the likes of Merrett, Parish, Caldwell, and Hobbs. Despite the uncertainty, Durham should be in your black book. If he does secure a midfield spot, he’ll offer great value, particularly as he’s likely to be picked later in drafts. Keep a keen eye on him during the preseason.
The Breakout Contenders
Ben Hobbs
Ben Hobbs had a slow start last season, breaking into Essendon’s team only after an injury to Will Setterfield and a dip in Dylan Shiel’s form. But once he got his chance, he certainly made an impact. Averaging 76.5 across the season, his stats were slightly skewed by a sub-affected score of 23 in his first game. Without that, his average would have been closer to 80, almost disqualifying him from this article. This season, Hobbs is set to start in Essendon’s best 22, likely as their third-string midfielder, which should comfortably see him average over 80. Hobbs possesses all the traits of an AFL Fantasy star, and if he puts it all together this season, we could be witnessing a breakout year for him.
Elijah Tsatas
Elijah Tsatas’ start to his AFL career was hindered by injuries, but he managed to make his debut late last season, showcasing some real potential. Despite an average of just 64 over his first four games, he notched an impressive score of 86 points in one of those outings. According to the breakout tracker, Tsatas’ early career performance is trending ahead of the top 20 midfielders and top 10 forwards in AFL Fantasy after their first four games. The fact that he’s listed as a forward this year is a boon, especially since he’s likely to see midfield action and score well. While it might take another year or two for Tsatas to become a fantasy powerhouse, there’s a chance he might break out this season. Securing him now could be a smart move, just in case he takes that big leap.
Archie Perkins
Archie Perkins saw about a 42% increase in his center bounce attendance last season when compared to his 2022 numbers, but his role remained somewhat inconsistent. He shifted between being stationed up forward and playing as a midfielder. For Perkins to become a more reliable fantasy scorer, he needs to secure a permanent role in one of these positions, but it’s uncertain if this will happen. He’s quite effective up forward and also shows promise in the midfield, suggesting he might continue to play dual roles. The silver lining is that this versatility should maintain his forward status in fantasy leagues. Ideally, if he can find that sweet spot of playing around 65% in the midfield and 35% up forward, he could find some good middle ground in his fantasy scoring.
The Stash Options
Nick Bryan
Nick Bryan, a young ruckman, presents an intriguing prospect in AFL fantasy. At first glance, his overall numbers might not seem impressive, but a closer look reveals solid performances in games where he played as the sole ruckman. At just 22, he still has time to develop, considering ruckmen typically peak developmentally around the age of 25. With Sam Draper’s injury concerns and Todd Goldstein appearing more as a temporary solution, Bryan could very well become Essendon’s primary ruckman in the future. Drafting and stashing Bryan now could be a wise move, as he shows potential to improve in the coming years.
Find out about the best draftees for AFL Fantasy in our ‘AFL Draft Fantasy Analysis 2022′ podcast exclusively for members.
Support the podcast by becoming a member.

