The 2025 AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft has delivered a fresh crop of fantasy prospects, with several state-league standouts offering intriguing potential for coaches seeking mid-season upgrades.
Tom McCarthy has been a standout in the VFL this season, averaging 83.1 fantasy points per game across seven matches for Richmond. His role as a rebounding defender, coupled with averages of 22.6 disposals, 4.1 marks, and 3.3 tackles per game, makes him an ideal mid-season fantasy pickup. Now drafted by West Coast with the first pick in the 2025 AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft, McCarthy is poised to debut in the coming weeks. Given the Eagles’ current defensive needs, he could see immediate AFL action.
Michael Sellwood is a competitive and versatile defender known for his ball-winning ability and strong marking. In the 2025 WAFL season with Peel Thunder, he averaged 23.7 disposals, 7.5 marks, and 3.3 tackles per game, culminating in an impressive 96.6 fantasy points per match. His consistent performance earned him a spot in the WAFL State team, where he contributed 19 disposals and 8 marks in their victory over South Australia.
Mani Liddy is a hard-nosed inside midfielder known for his consistency and leadership. Averaging 25.4 disposals per game for Central District in the SANFL this season, Liddy has established himself as one of the league’s elite midfielders. His standout performances earned him selection in the SANFL state team, where he impressed in his debut appearance. With an average of 86.9 fantasy points per game, Liddy offers some fantasy potential.
Archer May, a 198cm key forward, has impressed in the WAFL with Subiaco, averaging 81.8 fantasy points per game. His strong marking and goal-scoring abilities have been pivotal to his team’s performance. In the 2025 State Game, May contributed 13 disposals, 2 goals, and 5 tackles, showcasing his readiness for higher competition. While his WAFL fantasy average is solid, it’s important to note that key forwards often face challenges translating such numbers to the AFL level.
For a comprehensive overview, the table below lists the fantasy averages of all players selected in the 2025 mid-season draft:
